The idea that employees are losing sleep over being replaced by robots has become a hot topic. Everywhere you look, people are saying AI is going to take over most jobs soon. Headlines scream, “Automation will wipe out 97% of jobs by next week!”
But the reality is: employees aren’t actually terrified about robots snatching their roles. That doesn’t mean they’re not afraid, though.
What’s freaking them out? Turns out, employees are more scared of being replaced by another person than a robot. When it comes down to it, we’d rather a machine take our job than have Mark the intern take our spot.
The research shows that people generally feel more comfortable with the idea of others being replaced by technology than by another worker. But when it comes to their own jobs, the tables turn. Most workers find it less distressing to be replaced by AI or automation than by a human colleague.
This boils down to one thing: people don’t compare themselves to machines in the same way they do to other people.
Being replaced by another person can feel like a direct blow to self-worth, while being replaced by technology doesn’t trigger that same emotional reaction.
It makes sense. Getting replaced by another human stings because we naturally compare ourselves to them. The thought process might go, “Sure, a robot can handle this part of the job better than I can, but no way can Mark do it better!” Our egos can rationalize being outdone by technology, but not by someone we see as our equal.
Let’s be real: getting replaced by a robot makes sense since AI can do some things better than humans. But being replaced by another person? That’s a harder pill to swallow because it feels like a reflection of your value. And honestly, it’s way harder to explain to your family that your job was handed to someone else instead of a machine.
What I find interesting is the fear of the rise of AI in HR & TA, just generally speaking. We all know compliance is an issue still being worked out which takes forever (we’re still working off laws made 75+ yrs ago); the laws though moving a little quicker, will take a while to catch up to the ever-evolving tech.
Not to mention, us TA professionals take into account and measure the candidate experience. Over the years with the increase of automation and tech, there’s been a correlation increase in the number of candidates who tell me they’re thrilled to interact with a human vs. a machine. AI will never fully be able to remove the human from human resources.