Categories

Archived Posts

It’s Not a Talent Contest

Nov 5

I think most of us have gotten away from using the phrase “a war on talent’ throughout the industry.  It’s not really a war, and if it was most of you would lose.  Most talent acquisition shops are unwilling to do what it would take to win a war, that’s just a fact, not a shot at your shop.

There’s a better phrase that I think should encompass the plight of talent in our organizations that is used frequently in sports:

“It’s not a ‘talent’ contest. It’s a ‘winning’ contest!”

This means it doesn’t matter how talented the other team is, it all comes down to winning the game.  Great, you have the best talent, but if you’re losing the game/contest/event your high level of talent means nothing!

HR, Talent Acquisition and most executives have a hard time with this. They want to get the ‘best’ talent.  When, in reality, the best talent might not help your organization ‘win’.  Yes, you win or lose in most organizations.  You either make the sale or don’t make the sale. You either launch on time or don’t.  You either design award winning products, or you design products that never make it market.  Those are winning and losing in a business sense.

Business isn’t a talent game. It’s a winning and losing game.

What does this mean to HR and Talent Acquisition?  You don’t always need the most talented individuals to win.  What you need is people who are willing to give that little bit of extra effort, over those who won’t.  This discretionary effort gets you the win, over talented individuals who aren’t willing to give such effort.

You need individuals that put the goal, the vision, first.  Again, nothing to do with talent.  They believe in what you are doing as an organization, and do what it takes to make those goals reality.

You need individuals who want to see those around them succeed and are willing to sacrifice themselves, from time to time, to see their peers and coworkers succeed.  This sacrifice has nothing to do with talent.

I love talent, don’t get me wrong.  All of us need a certain level of talent to do what we do, but almost all of us don’t need to be the ‘most’ talented to be successful.  When we go out and build our talent strategies we have to be aware of this.  It’s not about hiring top talent.  It’s about hiring the talent that will make our organizations successful.

I don’t want my organization to be in a talent game.  I want my organization to be in a winning game.

6 Comment to “It’s Not a Talent Contest”

  1. I really like the distinction between talented people and people you need to make your business successful. Those people might be talented, but they also need to believe in the company, fit in with the culture, and put in the work to get it done. Great post.

    Nov 5, 2014
  2. Another hit, Tim – as my buddy Ian Williamson (MBS) suggested a few years ago, in the “war for talent,” talent won! And no doubt if the most talent always won, Brasil would take the World Cup every time… Keep up the great posts!

    Marcus Stewart
    Nov 5, 2014
  3. Great post Tim. It’s as if you read my mind. I was just thinking about the so called, “War on Talent,” this week. Keep up the good work!

  4. Great point and a debate I have had with leaders in the past.

    Championship teams are seldom comprised of exclusively of superstars. Most have 1 or 2 superstars that are surrounded by role players.

    It’s the journeymen and rookies that make the difference.

    Nov 5, 2014
  5. The War metaphor notwithstanding (enough Sacko – have you ever been in one?), spot on post. Wrote a post this weekend that employee engagement Is s recruiting issue that takes your thesis a bit farther: http://recruitinginferno.com/2014/11/02/employee-engagement-is-all-about-recruiting/

    Nov 5, 2014

Leave a Reply